How I voted for the Hall – and looking for your posts

MLB.com just posted the story on how its 15 eligible Hall of Fame voters filled out their ballots, and you can see mine among the list. I voted for five: Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, Ken Griffey Jr., Trevor Hoffman and Mike Piazza.

The excitement of receiving a ballot that has a name like Junior Griffey’s on it is the especially fun part of being a Hall voter. That is the kind of player the Cooperstown gallery room was created for — next to Ruth, Cobb, Aaron and Mays. You know that player when his five-year countdown begins and your vote is unquestionable. That brings us to everyone else on the 2016 list, and the effort to determine whether any other candidates should share the stage with him.

Neither Bonds nor Clemens exactly sweeps the Rule No. 5 categories on voting criteria, yet they are top-four all-time by position and that trumps character shortcomings. Hoffman was the first to 600 saves in an era when hitters dominated, and Piazza’s election is just overdue.

Jeff Bagwell continues to be an agonizing decision, more agonizing each year due to statistical analysis and debate. I disagree with those who “cover the field” with 10 safety check marks each year, as the bottleneck has declined. I can see both sides to Bagwell, and being on the fence is not a Hall vote to me unless you are covering the field.

The 2016 Hall of Fame results will be announced at 6 p.m. ET Wednesday on MLB.com and MLB Network.

The Unbiased MLB Fan identified four names that would be on his ballot, while Sons of ’84 has eight — plus a ninth vote for a write-in. Darryl of 210Sports explains the rationale behind his would-be ballot, and The First 90 Feet sees a ballot so packed that some worthy names will need to wait. The Wayniac Nation views Ken Griffey, Jr. and Trevor Hoffman as no-brainers (and hopes Tim Raines will get in at last), and Baseball with Matt adds Billy Wagner to the list of deserving former stars in their first year of Hall eligibility. The Baseball Continuum looks at the recent decision by the Veterans Committee to not induct anyone, while Statis Pro 1978 Replay looks at Alan Trammell’s last hurrah and Yankeebiscuitfan argues for more closers in Cooperstown.

Who would you have chosen? Please add the URL of your own blog post about the Hall vote in the comments below so we can see everyone’s opinions. And as always, be sure to follow MLB.com/blogs to see daily surfacing of great posts around our community.

Happy New Year,

– Mark Newman

4 Comments

My column will go up tomorrow with how I voted. If I may ask, Mark, why no vote for Tim Raines?

Hi, hope all is well. I never thought he was a Hall of Famer when I was covering him as a beat writer during his career, in his heyday. Now that I immerse myself like everyone else in the statistical conversations long after his career, I am on the fence with him. And I will never vote for anyone if I am on the fence. I go to the Gallery room at Cooperstown often and talk to families and those are the people I vote for. I consider it a privilege to vote what I know. I respect that many will disagree, but I do not view him as Hall-worthy, a prized honor for the greatest to ever play. For what it’s worth I didn’t vote for Andre Dawson, either, so I guess I am not on the top of old Expo fans’ list. Happy New Year and enjoy 2016. – Mark/MLB.com

Hi Mark…Happy New Year! So happy you included Italian American great Mike Piazza on you ballot. You might enjoy reading why I consider him to be Italian American of the Decade: http://mlbforlife.com/2014/03/22/why-mike-piazza-is-italian-american-of-the-decade/

All the best in 2016,

Roberto Angotti AKA MLBblogger

Reblogged this on MLB.com Blogs and commented:

Happy Hall of Fame Week. Here’s how I voted on my Hall ballot, and we’re looking to showcase your own posts about your thoughts on this year’s ballot.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: